top of page
  • Captain May

Best in Cape May 2021

Updated: Mar 6, 2022

From blog, here is the Best of Cape May 2021


What’s the best place to get…

Women’s Clothing: Cotton Company

Runner up: Cash & Clive

Men’s Clothing: Galvanic

Runner up: Cotton Company

Children’s Clothing: It’s a tie between Arden’s Kids and Happy Baby

Runner up: Tommy’s Folly

T-shirts and Sweatshirts: It’s a Breeze

Runner up: It’s a tie between Great White Shark and The Flying Fish Studio

Shoes: Casales

Runner up: Galvanic

Accessories: Red Oak Trading

Runner up: Whale’s Tale

Jewelry: Henry’s

Runner up: Whale’s Tale

Surf & Swimwear: South End Surf Shop

Runner up: Pete Smith’s Surf Shop

Handbags & Totes: Red Oak Trading

Runner up: Queen May

Candy & Fudge: The Original Fudge Kitchen

Runner up: Fralinger’s

Gifts: Whale’s Tale

Runner up: Sunset Beach Gift Shops

Home Decor: Cape May Wicker

Runner up: Whale’s Tale

Art: SOMA Gallery

Runner up: Three-way tie between Cape May Snaps, Cape May Art Gallery, and Gallery D’May

Antiques: West End Garage

Runner up: Out of the Past Antiques

Gourmet / Specialty Food: Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

Runner up: Cape May Olive Oil Co.

Toys: Whale’s Tale

Runner up: Toy Store of Cape May

Pet Accessories: Dog Days of Cape May

Runner up: The Wagging Tail

Cape May Souvenirs: Sunset Beach Gift Shops

Runner up: Whale’s Tale

Bath & Body: Bath Time

Runner up: Shore Soaps

Liquor or Wine: Collier’s

Runner up: Sunset Liquors


Who has the best…

Coffee: Coffee Tyme

Runner up: Magic Brain

Cold/Frozen Drinks: Coffee Tyme

Runner up: Harry’s Bar and Grill

Pancakes: Uncle Bill’s Pancake House

Runner up: Mad Batter

Brunch: Mad Batter

Runner up: Blue Pig Tavern

Breakfast Sandwich: Coffee Tyme

Runner up: Bagel Time Cafe

Hot Dog: Hot Dog Tommy’s

Runner up: Dawgtown Dogs

Wings: C-View

Runner up: Tie between Ugly Mug and Lucky Bones

Burger: It’s a tie between Exit Zero Filling Station and the Ugly Mug

Runner up: Lucky Bones

Fish/Shrimp Tacos: Taco Cabalito

Runner up: Key West Tacos

Sandwich, wrap, or hoagie: West Side Market

Runner up: Wawa

Pizza: Mario’s

Runner up: Lucky Bones

Appetizers: Harry’s Bar and Grill

Runner up: Lucky Bones

Seafood: The Lobster House

Runner up: Oyster Bay

Scallops: The Lobster House

Runner up: Mayer’s Tavern

Crabcakes: The Lobster House

Runner up: Freda’s Cafe

Oysters on the half shell: The Lobster House

Runner up: Oyster Bay

Mussels: The Lobster House

Runner up: Lucky Bones

Mexican: La Dona

Runner up: El Pueblo Taqueria

Italian: Sapore Italiano

Runner up: Panico’s

Steak: The Washington Inn

Runner up: Primal

Sushi: Yozu

Runner up: Momiji

Chinese, Japanese, or Thai: Yozu

Runner up: Momiji

Vegetarian / Vegan: It’s a tie between Good Earth Organic Eatery and Bella Vida

Runner up: The Mad Batter

Fries: Lucky Bones

Runner up: Three-way tie between Harry’s Bar and Grill, Hot Dog Tommy’s, and Fried Cape May (in the Akroteria)

Salads: Harry’s Bar and Grill

Runner up: George’s Place

Dessert: Peace Pies

Runner up: Chez Michel

Ice cream, custard, or gelato: Kohr Bros

Runner up: A tie between Peace Pies and Uncle Charley’s

Baked goods & pastries: Chez Michel

Runner up: Madison Bakery

Takeout: Homestyle to Go

Runner up: The Lobster House

Best options for kids: Rusty Nail

Runner up: Oceanview Diner

Best place to eat outside: The Lobster House

Runner up: Rusty Nail

Best view from the table: Harry’s Bar and Grill

Runner up: The Lobster House

A restaurant worth the splurge: The Washington Inn

Runner up: Peter Shields Inn

6 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page